The Scottish Enlightenment and American Slavery with Gideon Mailer

On Monday, November 16, the Center of Theological Inquiry welcomed Gideon Mailer for a lively discussion of his recent book The Character of Freedom: The Scottish Enlightenment and American Slavery (University Press of Kansas: American Political Thought Series, 2026).

Most people wouldn’t immediately associate American slavery with the Scottish Enlightenment.

Dr. Mailer, Professor of History at the University of Minnesota—Duluth, illuminated not only the connection between the two, but also made a compelling case for the myriad ways in which Scottish Enlightenment philosophers might have directly influenced the thought and work of abolitionists in the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century Atlantic world.

Delving into a vast archive of ideas—from Francis Hutcheson’s sentimentalism to Ottobah Cugoano’s moralism to David Hume’s skepticism to Black Presbyterians’ radicalism—Mailer elegantly examined the unique combination of Enlightenment and Evangelical ideas that made it possible for abolitionists across the Atlantic to articulate their hopes for a new world.


Mailer bears up The Character of Freedom as an offering at a pivotal moment in American history, amidst the nation’s celebration of the 250th anniversary of its founding—with the concept of liberty so instrumental to that founding and indeed to modern American identity. And it’s hard to have a meaningful conversation about American liberty without considering its limits, both ideologically and in practice. Freedom in the year 2026 has not quite unburdened itself from its contradictions, and from the legacy of the nation’s enslaving founders.

Even so, Mailer’s unearthing of the manifold means by which abolitionists grappled with the philosophical contradictions of slavery offers a useful framework for those seeking to create a better and more just world today. Navigating contradiction is perhaps simply part of the pursuit of liberty—and makes it no less worthy or possible of a pursuit. Fittingly, Mailer’s visit to CTI this week coincided with CTI’s ongoing From Despair to Hope project.

Before arriving at the University of Minnesota, Mailer received his PhD under the supervision of Betty Wood; his MA; and his BA (honors; Double-First Class), all from the University of Cambridge. Afterward, he was an elected Title A Junior Research Fellow of St John’s College, University of Cambridge, where he lectured and supervised in American and Atlantic history and in the history of intellectual thought.

As a scholar and teacher, Mailer “invites students and readers on a journey through the remarkable evolution of liberty, beginning with the ancient Anglo-Scottish constitutional framework and culminating in the establishment of the United States of America.” The word evolution seems key.

Etymologically, evolution means “an opening of what was rolled up,” from the Latin evolutionem, “unrolling (of a book).” David’s invitation evokes liberty not as something simply won and celebrated. Instead, his language suggests that liberty is an ongoing process that we might undertake, even write together.

-Rachael Uwada Clifford, Social Impact Fellow

Next
Next

David Cunningham Examines Work and Vocation in Theological Perspective